Peer Review Process

All manuscripts of  JTekEL: Jurnal Teknik Elektro are reviewed by blind reviewers consisting of an editor and members of the Editorial Board or qualified outside/external reviewers. This is done within the shortest given time. The journal,  above all, strives to return  reviewers  comments  to authors  within  3 weeks. The Editorial Board re-review  manuscripts  that are accepted until they are revised.

There are 6 Core Stages of Peer Review :
  • Manuscript Submission: The author uploads the paper, cover letter, and datasets through the journal's management system (e.g., Editorial Manager, OJS).
  • Desk Screening: The Editor-in-Chief checks if the paper fits the journal's scope, follows formatting guidelines, and passes plagiarism checks.
  • Reviewer Assignment: The editor invites 2–3 independent experts (peer reviewers) in the exact sub-field.
  • Evaluation & Peer Assessment: Reviewers critically analyze the methodology, novelty, data validity, ethical compliance, and clarity. They typically use a Double-Blind model (neither the author nor the reviewer knows each other's identity).
  • Editorial Decision: Based on the reviewers' reports, the editor issues one of four decisions: Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Reject.
  • Revision and Resubmission: The author revises the text and submits a point-by-point response letter detailing how they addressed each critique.